Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Energy, Environment and Tech committee get Cap and Trade overview

Rich Walje, President of Rocky Mountain Power, spoke about the federal cap and trade issue before the interim joint legislative committee on Energy, Environment and technology.

- Rocky Mountain Power serves customers in southeast Idaho. It customer-base is about 50% industrial.
- Fifty percent of the power it produces comes from coal-based generation.
- It is also the 2nd largest owner and operator of wind power in America.

Walje said Rocky Mountain Power supports the need to reduce carbon emissions and other greenhouse gas emissions but does not support a cap and trade program like the Waxman-Markley legislation that passed the U.S. House of Representatives. The issue is not renewable versus non-renewable energy. It’s about the best way to reduce carbon emissions. Walje suggests giving Rocky Mountain Power a target for reduction and letting the company figure out the best way to get there.

Walje noted the federal legislation being discussed does not take into account the growth rate in the need for electricity. There is no need for the trading associated with capping carbon emissions. Under Waxman-Markey, a company is given an allocation to emit one ton of carbon. It requires an emission allowance for every ton of carbon, not just the amount that is above the carbon cap. Waxman-Markey would only allow Rocky Mountain Power 55% of the allocations it would need. The company would have to buy the other 45% on the market. Those costs would be billed to its customers. An estimated $25 per ton for carbon equates to an average 16% price increase to the customer. This is before any costs to make changes that would actually reduce carbon. The average Rocky Mountain Power residential customer pays $3.00 a day for power. Those supporting Waxman-Markey point out that the cost is only as a much as postage stamp ($.44). They avoid mentioning that that is a cost per day which equals $13.38 additional cost per month. Under the House legislation, allocations go to companies that do not need them because they have lower carbon emissions. They sell them on the market to companies like Rocky Mountain Power that don’t get enough allocations--essentially transferring money from Rocky Mountain Power customers to the sellers of the allocations. None of this reduces carbon emissions, Walje says, it is, rather, a transfer of wealth. The trading regime is not limited to those who produce electricity. Wall Street will be involved and taking a cut.

Walje pointed out that 25% of the votes for Waxman-Markey in the U.S. House of Representatives came from New York and California. Is it a coincidence, he asks, that these are two states that will benefit the most from moving money? We can cap carbon emissions but with a cap and trade scheme, the customers pay twice: once for the trading costs and then again for the cost to actually reduce levels of carbon emissions. There is no economic development without electricity. Walje stressed the need to balance economic development, environmental impacts, and affordable electricity.

A member of the committee asked Walje why cap and trade won’t work for carbon reduction when it seemed to work well in reducing sulfur dioxide and acid rain. Walje responded that that program did not involve Wall Street traders. It did not give allocations to those who did not produce sulfur dioxide. In closing, Walje said that we don’t need the trading part of cap and trade to reduce carbon emissions. He would like to set up a plan to reach carbon reductions and work with the state to accomplish that reduction.

Neil Colwell of Avista Corporation made brief comments following Walje’s presentation. Avista, he says, is one of those companies that might be termed a “winner” in the cap and trade system because it doesn’t have coal generation. There would be less impact on its customers but there would still be a cost impact. If the price of allowances goes too high, the U.S. economy could suffer. Therefore, a reasonable ceiling on the price of emission allowances is needed. An allowance price floor may also be necessary to encourage investments in emission reduction technology. Avista supports allocation of allowances based on electricity output or sales and opposes allocation based on historic emissions. Allowances should be allocated to load serving utilities with the benefits passed on to customers. The Edison Electric Institute allocation compromise that splits the difference between emission-based and load-based allocation is reasonable. Colwell also commented that there were more solutions available in dealing with sulfur dioxide and acid rain.

Transmission Projects update to the Interim Committee on Energy, Environment and Technology, October 21, 2009

Paul Kjellander, Administrator of the Idaho Office of Energy Resources gave an update on transmission projects that cross the state. The Gateway West project by Idaho Power that crosses southern Idaho into Wyoming is the furthest along. The BLM is looking at the Environmental Impact Statement. Another Idaho Power transmission project, the Boardman-Hemingway project, has had some fits and starts but now there is good progress.

Another project has been permitted since 1996. Ellis Power took over the corridor before the internment camp at Minidoka became a National Historic Site. Ellis Power looked for an alternate route around the camp but there are efforts to add more land to the site. Objections to the route based on viewshed have been raised. The issue seems to be a way to stop the transmission line because the “viewshed” already includes a K-V line and distribution lines. It does, however, appear that there has been positive movement lately.

The Forest Service, BLM and the National Park Service have different approaches when it comes to transmission lines. Kjellander noted a need for a more unified and streamlined process for the utilities, stressing that transmission is vital to development of renewable energy.

With regard to transmission project, Kjellander noted that “bugs and bunnies, varmints and vermin" as protected by the ESA will be key issues.

He also noted that FERC backup authority is included in the Waxman-Markey bill but would only apply to the western states.

Kjellander pointed out that we cannot access a lot of federal land, but federal land will be a key piece in getting transmission built. There has been some work on mapping to guide developers on where the mitigation efforts would be least expensive on federal land. This must be coordinated among the states so that the gradation maps make sense. Right now federal policies are in conflict. The federal government supports renewable energy but has other policies that bar us from access to the land that is needed for transmission.

* * * * *

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Legislative Energy, Environment and Technology Interim Committee Updates

The Joint Energy, Environment and Technology Interim Committee met early this month for updates on transmission projects, a proposal for the establishment of Energy Independence Districts, how projects utilizing woody biomass are progressing (or aren’t), and how the Governor’s Office of Energy Resources is poised to utilize stimulus funding.

Transmission Project Siting
Ron Williams from LS Power updated the Committee on the progress of two transmission projects that will form a regional transmission hub through southern Idaho and that together represent more than 1,000 miles of transmission: The Southwest Intertie Project (SWIP) and the Overland Intertie Project (OIP). The SWIP will be the most advanced high voltage project in the west. Construction on this $1 billion capital investment project is slated to begin next year. It will provide a connection to areas southwest of Idaho where renewable energy generation is available. The OIP represents east/west transmission to and from points in eastern Wyoming.

LS Power is still engaged in siting both of these projects and is including public input in an alternate routing study currently underway. The preferred route is through the site established through right of way established through the Gateway West Transmission Plan.

Energy Independence Districts
Reporting on behalf of the Idaho Department of Commerce, Lane Packwood described a legislative initiative the department is developing for residences and small businesses to finance renewable energy projects. Their intention is to remove financial barriers to consumers – who want to retrofit their properties – by developing a framework for property secured municipal financing. Packwood noted that 12 other states have established laws allowing municipalities to establish local improvement districts. Such districts would be opt-in rather than geographically defined, and would allow for a tax assessment on the property to finance improvements at a much lower interest rate and longer term than traditional financing.

Senator Kate Kelly noted that her biggest concern is the constitutionality of the proposed legislation, although Packwood asserted that at least 4 other states had similar concerns regarding constitutionality and found ways to address them.

Senator Kelly remained skeptical. “What we have seen, time after time, is the legislature doing something creative with the constitution,” she said, “and seeing it challenged in court.”

Woody Biomass
If you have been tracking the developments of this committee for a while, you may be wondering about whether anything has developed with the utilization of woody biomass as a renewable resource. Examples of woody biomass projects in Council and Kellogg have been touted as successful: heating schools and other public buildings at a fraction of the cost and emissions of coal or fuel oil.

Experts note, when looking at all other sources of renewable energy combined, biomass is the only renewable energy source that can close the gap in the 25’x25’ initiative: a nonpartisan public policy initiative to get 25 percent of our energy from renewable resources like wind, solar and biofuels by the year 2025. Idaho is participating in the initiative as a part of the 2007 state Energy Plan.

Several members of the committee have expressed concern for the lack of development in this area. Who is coordinating efforts? Among the issues to be resolved is access to biomass material – which can be expensive to gather, bundle and haul. Jim Reilly of the Intermountain Forest Association noted that a lack of technology is not the impediment to this sector, and that there are small forests that could supply the market, plus substantial fiber available on federal lands. The problem is the gridlock that keeps those lands from contributing to this market. The best opportunities in the biomass industry come from improving the efficiencies in moving biomass from the forest to the power plant.

Representative Eric Anderson voiced extreme frustration with the red tape associated with accessing biomass material on federal lands.

“You should be paying people to take dead and dying material out of the forest, not charging them a permit fee,” he said to US Forest Service’s Andy Brunelle.

The committee elected to draft a letter to the Governor’s Office of Energy Resources, strongly encouraging it to take a lead on the woody biomass issue. They also voted to send a letter strongly encouraging the Idaho Department of Lands to grant stewardship grants for access to fuel sources for periods of ten years or more.

Stimulus Money to Fund Energy Audits for Schools
The committee heard from the Governor’s Office of Energy Resources about their plans to utilize $30 million in stimulus funding to conduct energy audits on each of the 700 schools in Idaho. The state has until 2015 to conduct the audits and make the repairs. The OER has recruited Maria Barratt from the Department of Financial Management to oversee the management of the stimulus funding. Thus far, the OER has contracted with licensed engineers from across the state to conduct the audits.

Is It a Resolution or isn’t it?
Senator Elliot Werk submitted draft copy for a concurrent resolution that would clarify responsibilities outlined in the 2007 Energy Plan and ask for a detailed report from the Office of Energy Resources every two years.

The 2007 Energy Plan was established before the OER, which has the responsibility for energy planning, policy and coordination in the state of Idaho and should, says Senator Werk, be held accountable for addressing the plan and how they’re spending stimulus funds.

Some discussion was held as to whether a concurrent resolution was the proper vehicle for this message, or if a letter outlining expectations would be more appropriate. Senator Patty Anne Lodge wondered if the committee should be asking the agencies to add to their already considerable workload.

Representative Wendy Jaquet pointed out that this committee has fallen short of its duties by not outlining specific accountabilities to the Public Utilities Commission as aligned with the Energy Plan.

Co-chair George Eskridge noted that Idaho could expect to receive federal mandates. “We’re in a far more serious position than we were two years ago,” he said. “All we’re asking for is a report.” The committee will invite the PUC to present at the next meeting on their alignment to the Energy Plan and on efforts to establish shareholder incentives to meet efficiency targets.

Who should pay for new growth?
House Bill 52 was introduced last year, which would allow the PUC to assign some of the costs of utility development to new growth. Upon its introduction, it was met with opposition from realtors and contractors who had no input in its development. Representative Bert Stevenson noted that they’re planning to reintroduce the bill, inviting opponents to submit their input. The Supreme Court has ruled that new growth can’t be responsible for paying all of the costs for new utilities. Legislation going forward needs to address how the partial costs of construction could be allocated to new growth.

Codification of the Office of Energy Resources
The Office of Energy Resources is currently a creature of the Governor’s executive order which has approximately the force of law but not quite, according to Senator Kelly. If the office is codified, it would be continued from one administration to another. Senator Kelly has met with Director Kjellander and David Hensley of the governor’s office and got a lot of input from them. Senator Kelly asked for input from the committee on her draft proposal to codify the Office of Energy Resources.

Renewable & Energy Conservation Tax Credit
John Watts made a presentation on a piece of legislation for one of his clients: Renewable & Energy Conservation Tax Credit. It has been through three drafts so far.

Thirty-nine other states have a renewable energy tax credit.

It’s a proposed 35% investment tax credit on facilities located in Idaho for con-generation facilities. Some with no taxable income could pass the credit along to someone else who can use the tax credit. This is not to exceed $20 million on overall project cost.

The program would reside within the Office of Energy Resources and be financed by taking 5% for administration. Investors could re- capture 7% per year.

Other Stimulus Projects
Ken Eckland for Office of Energy Resources outlined the projects that are being funded with stimulus funds:
- Energy tune-ups for energy efficiency: $17 million

- Pilot project on solar roofs for five schools. $2,750,000. A consultant will audit to make sure the most competitive projects are funded.

- Renewable Energy Enterprise Zones Project forming private-public partnerships for renewable energy projects: $1,500,000

- Micron Technology LED conversion to produce LED lighting at its existing Boise facility. The research and development is on track to convert the lines that have been shut down to produce light emitting diodes. DOE approached Micron for a proposal: $5 million.

- Competitive block grant for smaller cities and counties: $5.5 million. OER is encouraging cities and counties to team up for projects.

- Methane gas project: $1.15 million.

- Building code upgrades: $500,000.

- Biomass: $500,000.

- PV Solar: $300,000.

The next meeting of the Energy, Environment and Technology Interim Committee has been scheduled for October 21st and 22nd.

Thursday, August 6, 2009

Working Lands Coalition provides multiple perspectives

At the July meeting of the Natural Resources interim committee, the Idaho Working Lands Coalition provided an overview of the changing landscape in Idaho and the importance of conserving Idaho’s ranches, farms and forests. The Idaho Tax Commission shows that 13.8 million acres in Idaho were taxed as private working lands in 2008. When considering Idaho’s population growth (projected to be 2 million by 2030), and the financial incentive landowners have to sell or develop working lands rather than preserve them, projections from three different land use studies show a sharp increase in the conversion and development of working lands to other uses.

Conversion of working lands can have a number of impact including changes to the economic contribution of the land, restricting access to public lands, a change in the demand for water, habitat, tax base and demand for support services.

The Coalition introduced representatives from rural north, central and eastern Idaho to share their perspectives on the importance of working lands in their respective areas. Items of particular concern for example in eastern Idaho include the dwindling resources for rangeland available for grazing to supply the beef industry. In northern Idaho, the conversion of forest lands adversely impact the timber industry. The committee discussed a Minnesota program for incentivizing the conservation of working lands as such. Those funds come from the state general fund.

Emma Atchley a Fremont County farmer supported conservation easements as a tool to maintain land in farming. She pointed out that there is a problem with developers going bankrupt. The farmers that sold land to them with the promise of a monetary return from the lots do not get any money. In some cases, infrastructure is developed so the land can no longer be farmed.

She also stated that while the state cannot commit to additional funds in the next legislative session with the downturn in the economy, we need to be looking at this as a long term issue and start preparing for better economic times.

Perspective from Federal and State Agencies

Jeff Burwell, representing the Natural Resources Conservation Service pointed out that the 2008 Farm Bill has a pretty substantial toolbox for conservation with about $38 million for use in Idaho. He distributed a chart and map showing land use changes in Idaho. Since 2003, Idaho has lost 278,000 acres of farm and ranch land. He discussed conservation programs to protect private working lands. These include:

ü The Farmland Protection Program which provides federal matching funds to help state, tribal
or local governments and NGO’s purchase easements to keep productive farm and ranchland in agricultural use.

ü The Wetlands Reserve Program which is a voluntary, non-regulatory, incentive-based program that may help landowners protect and restore wetlands on their property.

ü The Grassland Reserve Program which assists landowners to restore and protect grassland, rangeland, pastureland, shrub land and certain other lands, and provides assistance for restoration.

Sharon Kiefer, Idaho Department of Fish & Game discussed the importance of private working lands to the Department Private land ownership in Idaho is focused on those areas most productive for farms, ranches, and forests. These productive lands are also disproportionately important to fish and wildlife. The threat that IDFG sees is the fragmentation of fish and wildlife habitat from continued development and conversion of private working lands into smaller parcels.

Sharon described IDFG’s programs that help preserve private working lands including wildlife habitat improvements, the Access Yes program to provide voluntary access to private lands, the Mule Deer Initiative that brings department funding resource to private landowners to enhance the benefits from stewardship of wildlife habitat.

IDFG offers opportunities to reward stewardship, build capacity, capitalize on existing assets and promote partnership and collaboration.

The Idaho State Department of Agriculture’s Deputy Director, Brian Oakey, described Idaho’s Right to Farm Law and listed national trends in agriculture such as direct marketing of farm products, agritourism, and value added products processed on-stie.

In Idaho the number of farmer’s markets has doubled in three years. The number of Idaho wineries has doubled in the last five years. Eating locally gets more support than eating organic and more specialty items are being produced than ever before. Some traditional farmland protection tools are agricultural or large lot zoning, agricultural and forestry districts, conservation easements, purchase of development rights, use-value assessment for tax purposes and various forms of estate tax relief. Other tools might include smart growth, differential assessment programs, term easements, green payments of farm business succession planning.

Kathy Opp and David Groeschi of the Idaho Department of Lands discussed IDL programs such as the Statewide Assessments of Forest Resources (SAFR) and the Idaho Forest Legacy program. The SAFR helps to ensure wise investment of resources, identify critical forest issues and highest priority areas of impact in order to leverage resources through partnership to benefit forest management access across all ownerships.

Idaho’s Forest Legacy Program is meant to protect environmentally important forest areas that are threatened by conversion to non-forest uses. It was created in the 1990 Farm Bill and is a voluntary program with 75% federal funds and 25% non-federal match. There are not state funds used in the program Funds are used to purchase conservation easements on private forest land that might otherwise be developed or lost as working lands.

Nate Fisher, Idaho Office of Species Conservation (OSC), made the final presentation. Nate discussed the collaboration that has taken place through OSC to use federal salmon money to fund projects that benefit salmon restoration by restoring habitat while helping farmers and ranchers stay on their land.

Wild horse bill could impact local ecology

A bill being considered before the US Senate will restrict the authority of local agencies dealing with wild horses, and give a foothold to lawsuits, says Ron Kay with the Idaho State Department of Agriculture to the interim Natural Resources committee in late July.

The Restoration of the American Mustang Act aims to restore acreage available for wild and free-roaming horses and burros to at least that of 1971. Kay notes that wild horse populations double every four years. A federal wild horse adoption program returns any unadopted horses back to the rangeland – effectively postponing the problem. Among the tongue-in-cheek suggestions by committee members for dealing with expanding horse populations: opening up the National Mall in Washington DC as wild horse rangeland, or intermingling expanding horse and wolf populations.

Water rights curtailment order enforced in Southern Idaho

Chris Bromley of the Idaho Department of Water Resources gave the interim Natural Resources committee an update on three water calls which have been under review. The first two, dealing with the A&B Irrigation District and the Surface Water Coalition of 7 southern Idaho districts have been resolved, with the Department stating that they will strive to be as timely as possible in deciding such cases in the future.

The subject of the third call presented before the committee was the resolution of a 2005 suit brought by the Snake River Farm hatchery and Clear Springs Foods near Hagerman, Idaho. The question before the department is whether a senior water rights holder can be forced to accept cash in lieu of water and stems from a legal dispute over groundwater pumping. As a result of this call the Department has issued a curtailment order targeting water rights holders after 1981 in a 9,000 acre area. According to the Idaho Statesman this order “marks the first time the State has followed through on an edict requiring the closure of wells that irrigate crops and supply cheese factories, cities and golf courses with water.” http://www.idahostatesman.com/531/story/853051.html.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Western states to lose control over transmission siting?

The Pacific Northwest Economic Region (PNWER) is holding its 19th annual summit in Boise this week. The theme of the conference is Global Challenges, Northwest Imperatives for the Future. Following is an article published by NewWest.net about transmission siting in the West.

For further information about PNWER activities in Boise this week, go to: http://www.pnwer.org/2009summit/Home

Western States To Lose Control Over Transmission Siting?
'We don't know why or where it came from."
By Sharon Fisher, 7-13-09:

Newly added provisions to the Waxman-Markey cap-and-trade bill, next slated to be voted on by the U.S. Senate, give the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission final say over the siting of electric transmission lines in Western states—but not in any other part of the country, attendees of the Pacific Northwest Economic Region conference in Boise learned today.

There is a “real threat” of the federal government taking over, said Paul Kjellander, administrator of Idaho’s office of energy resources, noting that seven transmission lines are currently slated to crisscross Idaho.

One of the biggest issues is Gateway West, the siting of which is being fought by Parma and Kuna, which found out at recent public meetings that towers up to 180 feet tall along a corridor up to 250 wide were slated to cross the cities’ impact areas.

“Everyone agrees it’s essential,” Kjellander said. “What they can’t agree on is where it goes,” especially since some alternative routes could add up to $1 billion more to the project.
Siting of transmission lines are a major issue in the West; a lawsuit was filed earlier this month regarding the designation of a number of “energy corridors” here.

The Fourth Circuit court overturned a legal decision earlier this year regarding FERC power over site selection. “FERC had argued that the 2005 Energy Policy Act permitted it to order “national interest” transmission projects to go forward, and that Congress’ mandate included implicit authority to overrule state decisions to the contrary,” according to the Marten Law Group. “The Fourth Circuit disagreed, finding that if states turn down transmission projects on reasonable grounds, they cannot be overruled by FERC.” The case may end up going to the U.S. Supreme Court, the law group said.

It was after that, in May, when amendments were added to the The American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009 (ACES), H.R. 2454, commonly known as the Waxman-Markey bill, allowing FERC to pre-empt state decisions on siting, said Janice Adair, Washington liaison to the Western Climate Initiative, which is developing its own cap-and-trade plan.

“We don’t know why or where it came from,” Adair said, noting that the amendment came in a package about 3 am. “We’re going backwards to try to figure out how that happened. The Western states are very much opposed to that position,” she added.

“Under the newest draft, a “high-priority national transmission project"developer must first apply to a state to route transmission facilities,” the Marten Law Group said. “But if the state fails to approve the construction and routing within one year of application, rejects the application, or imposes “unreasonable” conditions on the project, FERC can step in and authorize the transmission line routing. The explicit authority to override a state’s rejection of a project is a direct response to the 4th Circuit decision.”

“The federal government isn’t likely to be as respectful of private lands” as the states are, Kjellander said. On the other hand, “Transmission is that key resource we need to be developing as quickly as we can,” he added. “Let’s not forget what happens if we don’t move forward.”